Lincoln Park, Michigan May Consider Breed-Specific Ordinance for “Pit Bulls”

By Editor
In Breed-Specific Legislation
Jan 14th, 2011
2 Comments
2320 Views

Editor’s note:  Why is it that “pit bulls” are singled out for separate consideration when the fatality in question involved a German shepherd mix and a Labrador mix?  Don’t get me wrong, I’m not advocating a breed-specific ordinance for any breed (and “pit bull” isn’t even a breed) but it is odd that the one fatality cited didn’t involve a so-called “pit bull” and yet they get singled out anyway.  If Lincoln Park is having a problem with free-roaming dogs (and notice I said dogs and not “pit bulls”) then how will a breed-specific ordinance help?  The same people who aren’t abiding by the law now won’t suddenly start doing so simply because additional legislation has been passed.   Lincoln Park should instead consider a dangerous dog (owner) law which targets irresponsible owners of all breeds.  These all-encompassing laws — which often include escalating fines and punishments for irresponsible dog owners — have historically proven incredibly effective as a deterrence.  Breed-specific legislation, however, has historically proven to be a dismal failure.

Please write the Lincoln Park Mayor and City Council here and politely inform them that breed-specific legislation in any form is ineffective, unenforceable, and unconstitutional.

From the News-Herald:

A study session on pit bulls and other dogs considered to be dangerous has been set by the City Council for 6:30 p.m. Tuesday [January 18, 2011] at City Hall, 1355 Southfield Road. 

Councilman Mark Kandes requested the study session to look at the community’s reactions to the issue.

“The reason for the meeting is twofold,” Kandes said. “To get initial flavor of what’s going on in the community and what’s going on in other communities, but also what’s going on with vicious animals in general to see what we need to do about our ordinances.”

Police in the city still are investigating the death in July of a 5-year-old boy who was mauled by two dogs in his home. Those animals are described as a German shepherd mixed breed and a smaller possibly Labrador mix.

Numerous reports have been filed with police in Downriver communities and throughout Michigan about people and other animals being attacked by pit bulls and other dogs.

…Mayor Frank Vaslo said he is hoping residents will come to the meeting to voice their opinions.

“I’m hoping the council will get enough information to make an informed and reasonable decision,” Vaslo said. “We want to forge a reasonable path for the city to follow as far as dangerous animals go.”

“I don’t believe banning is the answer,” Vaslo said. “We need to strengthen vicious animal ordinances, but I’m open to listening to the testimony by everyone and we’ll make the decision after that.”…

Read this article in its entirety here.

2 Responses to “Lincoln Park, Michigan May Consider Breed-Specific Ordinance for “Pit Bulls””

  1. Caveat says:

    Yeah, same thing here in Ontario.

    When we did our election survey in 2007, the response from govt candidates included a canned writeup that mentioned a fatality involving a Bullmastiff and a mauling involving two Dogues de Bordeaux (as well as an attack by a ‘pit bull’) as justification for the provincial ‘pit bull’ ban.

  2. Hey Caveat, nice to see you back. I enjoyed reading your “Courtus Interruptus” post.

    Ontario’s not the only one. Look at Saginaw, Michigan trying to propose BSL for 10 breeds based on nothing more than that long-debunked CDC dog-bite study. Have all 10 of these breeds been involved in attacks on citizens in Saginaw? (Not that that would justify BSL either, but it would at least allow one to draw a parallel between an event or events and the subsequent BSL proposal.)

    I also wish all the best of luck to folks in Winnipeg who are trying to overturn that ban as well. This article is a good write-up on what’s happening. I should post it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ERROR: si-captcha.php plugin: GD image support not detected in PHP!

Contact your web host and ask them to enable GD image support for PHP.

ERROR: si-captcha.php plugin: imagepng function not detected in PHP!

Contact your web host and ask them to enable imagepng for PHP.